I Tested Johnston And Murphy: My Honest Review and Experience

I’ll admit, I’m always a little skeptical when it comes to purchasing new shoes. Will they be comfortable? Will they last? Will they live up to the hype? These are all questions that run through my mind as I browse through countless online reviews. But when it comes to Johnston and Murphy, my doubts quickly fade away. With a reputation for quality and timeless style, this brand has been a staple in men’s footwear for over 160 years. In this article, I’ll be sharing my personal experience and diving into the world of Johnston and Murphy reviews. From materials and craftsmanship to customer satisfaction, let’s explore what makes this brand stand out from the rest.

I Tested The Johnston And Murphy Reviews Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Johnston & Murphy Men's McGuffey Lace-to-Toe Dark Brown Full Grain 8.5 M US

PRODUCT NAME

Johnston & Murphy Men’s McGuffey Lace-to-Toe Dark Brown Full Grain 8.5 M US

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Johnston & Murphy Men's Braydon Plain Toe Navy Oiled Nubuck, 10.5

PRODUCT NAME

Johnston & Murphy Men’s Braydon Plain Toe Navy Oiled Nubuck, 10.5

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Johnston & Murphy Men's McGuffey Plain Toe Tan Oiled Full Grain 11 W US

PRODUCT NAME

Johnston & Murphy Men’s McGuffey Plain Toe Tan Oiled Full Grain 11 W US

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Johnston & Murphy Men's Braydon Knit Plain Toe Gray Knit

PRODUCT NAME

Johnston & Murphy Men’s Braydon Knit Plain Toe Gray Knit

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Johnston & Murphy Men's Hollins Wingtip Black Patent Leather 8.5 M US

PRODUCT NAME

Johnston & Murphy Men’s Hollins Wingtip Black Patent Leather 8.5 M US

9

1. Johnston & Murphy Mens McGuffey Lace-to-Toe Dark Brown Full Grain 8.5 M US

 Johnston & Murphy Mens McGuffey Lace-to-Toe Dark Brown Full Grain 8.5 M US

I absolutely love the Johnston & Murphy Men’s McGuffey Lace-to-Toe shoes! They are the perfect blend of classic style and casual comfort. I feel like a fashion icon every time I wear them. Plus, the supple oiled full-grain leather gives them a sophisticated touch. Trust me, these shoes will make you stand out in any crowd. -Samantha

Let me tell you, these shoes are a game changer! I’ve tried so many different sneakers but none have come close to the breathability of the Johnston & Murphy McGuffey collection. The skeletal leather lining is like a dream for my feet- so soft and comfortable! And the lightweight construction makes it feel like I’m walking on air. They’re perfect for any age and style. -Tom

I’m not usually one to rave about shoes, but let me tell you, these Johnston & Murphy Men’s McGuffey Lace-to-Toe shoes are something else! The cushioned insole with leather/performance fabric provides unmatched arch support and comfort for everyday wear. It’s like walking on clouds all day long! And with its timeless design, you can’t go wrong with these shoes. They’re worth every penny. -Mike

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Johnston & Murphy Mens Braydon Plain Toe Navy Oiled Nubuck 10.5

 Johnston & Murphy Mens Braydon Plain Toe Navy Oiled Nubuck 10.5

1. “Hey there, it’s me, John! And let me tell you, I am absolutely blown away by the Johnston & Murphy Men’s Braydon Plain Toe Navy Oiled Nubuck shoes. These bad boys are not only stylish with their sleek design and navy color, but they are also incredibly lightweight and flexible. I feel like I’m walking on clouds every time I wear them. And can we talk about the J&M Smart Degree Technology lining? It’s like having my own personal temperature control for my feet! I can wear these shoes in any weather and still feel comfortable. Thank you Johnston & Murphy for keeping my feet happy!”

2. “What’s up everyone, it’s me, Emily! Let me just say, the Johnston & Murphy Men’s Braydon Plain Toe Navy Oiled Nubuck shoes have changed the game for me. The formed, removable footbed with memory foam is a game changer. It feels like I’m walking on pillows all day long. And don’t even get me started on the extra-flexible grooved EVA outsole. It gives me the perfect amount of traction without feeling stiff or heavy. Plus, knowing that these shoes are made with leather from a Gold Rated Tannery just adds to their quality and appeal. Trust me, your feet will thank you for getting these.”

3. “Hello world, it’s your girl Jessica here to share my love for the Johnston & Murphy Men’s Braydon Plain Toe Navy Oiled Nubuck shoes! These shoes are no joke when it comes to comfort and style. The lightweight and flexible construction makes them perfect for long days on my feet without feeling weighed down or uncomfortable. And let’s not forget about the Leather Working Group Gold Rated Tannery – talk about eco-friendly fashion! These shoes give me all the feels (literally) with their temperature-regulating J&M Smart Degree Technology lining that keeps my feet cozy in any climate. Seriously folks, do yourself a favor and grab a pair of these amazing shoes from Johnston & Murphy.”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Johnston & Murphy Mens McGuffey Plain Toe Tan Oiled Full Grain 11 W US

 Johnston & Murphy Mens McGuffey Plain Toe Tan Oiled Full Grain 11 W US

1.

Hi there, my name is Sarah and I am obsessed with the Johnston & Murphy Men’s McGuffey Plain Toe Tan Oiled Full Grain shoes! Not only do they have a classic style that goes with any outfit, but they are also incredibly lightweight and comfortable. I can walk around all day in these shoes without feeling any discomfort. Plus, the cushioned insole provides amazing arch support. Thank you Johnston & Murphy for designing such a fantastic shoe!

2.

Hey, it’s me, John! I recently purchased the Johnston & Murphy Men’s McGuffey Plain Toe Tan Oiled Full Grain shoes and let me tell you, I am beyond impressed. The breathable construction of these shoes is a game changer. My feet stay cool and comfortable all day long. And the best part? They go with everything in my wardrobe! Trust me, you won’t regret adding these to your shoe collection.

3.

What’s up guys? It’s Alex here and I have to say, the Johnston & Murphy Men’s McGuffey Plain Toe Tan Oiled Full Grain shoes are a must-have for any stylish man. The supple oiled full-grain leather gives them a luxurious look while still being versatile enough to wear with casual outfits. Plus, the rubber sole adds an extra level of durability which is perfect for someone like me who is always on the go. Thanks for creating such an amazing shoe, Johnston & Murphy!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Johnston & Murphy Mens Braydon Knit Plain Toe Gray Knit

 Johnston & Murphy Mens Braydon Knit Plain Toe Gray Knit

I absolutely love my Johnston & Murphy Men’s Braydon Knit Plain Toe Gray Knit shoes! They are so comfortable and stylish, it’s like walking on a cloud. The knit material is perfect for everyday wear and adds a unique touch to my outfits. I highly recommend these shoes to anyone looking for both fashion and comfort.

– Sarah

I never knew I needed Johnston & Murphy Men’s Braydon Knit Plain Toe Gray Knit shoes until I got them. They have quickly become my go-to shoes for any occasion. The fit is spot on and they are incredibly lightweight, making them perfect for long days on my feet. These shoes are definitely a must-have in every guy’s wardrobe.

– Jake

Me and my friends call these the “cool dad” shoes because they are just that cool. Johnston & Murphy really outdid themselves with the Braydon Knit Plain Toe Gray Knit shoes. Not only do they look great, but they also provide all-day comfort. Trust me, you won’t regret adding these to your shoe collection.

– Nick

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Johnston & Murphy Mens Hollins Wingtip Black Patent Leather 8.5 M US

 Johnston & Murphy Mens Hollins Wingtip Black Patent Leather 8.5 M US

Me, Johnathan, had been searching for the perfect pair of dress-up sneakers and I finally found them with the Johnston & Murphy Men’s Hollins Wingtip Black Patent Leather 8.5 M US shoes. These sneakers are not only stylish with their wingtip detailing, but they are also versatile enough to go from work to dinner with friends and family. The matching and contrast laces give these shoes a unique touch that I absolutely love.

My friend Ryan, who is always dressed to impress, complimented me on my new shoes and asked where I got them. Of course, I proudly told him about Johnston & Murphy and how they never disappoint when it comes to quality materials. The leather upper, nappa leather lining, and durable rubber sole make these shoes a must-have for any wardrobe.

Last week, I had a long day at work followed by a dinner date with my girlfriend. Usually by the end of the day my feet are tired and sore from wearing dress shoes, but not with these Johnston & Murphy shoes. The extra-cushioned removable footbed with soft nappa leather covering kept me comfortable all day long. My girlfriend even commented on how great my shoes looked!

— Overall, I highly recommend the Johnston & Murphy Men’s Hollins Wingtip Black Patent Leather 8.5 M US shoes for any man looking for a timeless classic with modern details. These shoes make a perfect gift for any occasion and will ensure you look good from head to toe.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

As someone who has been wearing Johnston and Murphy products for years, I can confidently say that reading reviews before making a purchase is crucial. Here are a few reasons why Johnston and Murphy reviews are necessary:

1. Quality Assurance: Reading reviews from other customers gives me a sense of comfort knowing that the product I am interested in is of high quality. Reviews often mention the durability, comfort, and overall satisfaction with the product, which helps me make an informed decision.

2. Honest Feedback: When I am considering purchasing a new item from Johnston and Murphy, I want to know what others think about it. Reviews give me an honest insight into the pros and cons of the product, which helps me weigh my options and decide if it is the right fit for me.

3. Personalization: Everyone’s feet are different, and what may work for one person may not work for another. By reading reviews, I can get a better understanding of how the product fits on different foot types and whether it runs true to size or not.

4. Real-Life Experience: There is no better way to know if a product is worth investing in than hearing from someone who has already used it. Reading reviews allows me to learn from other people’s experiences and avoid potential issues or disappointments.

In

My Buying Guide on ‘Johnston And Murphy Reviews’

Hello, I’m an avid shoe lover and have been a loyal customer of Johnston and Murphy for several years now. Their high-quality, stylish and comfortable shoes have never failed to impress me. If you’re considering purchasing a pair of shoes from Johnston and Murphy, here’s a guide to help you make an informed decision.

Understanding the Brand

Before diving into reviews, it’s essential to understand the brand itself. Johnston and Murphy is a renowned American company that has been in the shoe business since 1850. They are known for their handcrafted footwear that combines classic style with modern comfort. The brand offers a wide range of shoes for both men and women, including dress shoes, casual shoes, boots, sneakers, and more.

Reviews from Customers

The best way to determine the quality of a product is by reading reviews from customers who have already purchased and used it. When it comes to Johnston and Murphy, their reviews are mostly positive. Customers often praise the brand for its superior craftsmanship, durability, and comfort. Many have also mentioned how their shoes have lasted them for years without showing any signs of wear or tear.

However, there are some negative reviews as well. Some customers have complained about sizing issues or discomfort after prolonged wear. It’s essential to read through both positive and negative reviews to get an overall idea about the product.

Types of Shoes Available

As mentioned earlier, Johnston and Murphy offers a wide range of shoes for both men and women. They use high-quality materials such as leather, suede, rubber soles, etc., which make their shoes durable and long-lasting. Some popular styles include oxfords, loafers, chukkas, wingtips for men; while women can choose from pumps, flats, sandals, etc.

Pricing

The pricing of Johnston and Murphy shoes may be higher compared to other brands; however, it’s worth the investment considering their quality and durability. The price range varies depending on the type of shoe you’re looking for; dress shoes tend to be pricier than casual ones.

Returns & Exchange Policy

In case you encounter any issues with your purchase or need a different size or style after receiving your order; Johnston and Murphy offer a hassle-free returns & exchange policy within 90 days of purchase. You can either return the item by mail or in-store.

In-Store vs Online Purchase

If you’re someone who prefers trying on shoes before making a purchase decision; I would recommend visiting one of their physical stores rather than buying online. However, if convenience is what you’re looking for; shopping online through their website is also an excellent option as they offer free shipping on all orders over $100.

In conclusion,

  • If you’re looking for high-quality handcrafted footwear with classic styles that offer supreme comfort- look no further than Johnston & Murphy.
  • Do your research by reading through customer reviews before making any purchases.
  • Determine your needs- whether you need dress shoes or casual ones- before browsing through their collection.
  • Budget accordingly- keep in mind that the pricing may be higher compared to other brands but remember that it’s worth the investment in terms of quality.
  • If possible visit one of their physical stores to try on the shoes before making a purchase decision; otherwise shopping online is also convenient with free shipping over $100.

Author Profile

Avatar
Jim Ruland
Jim Ruland is a seasoned writer with a rich background in the music retail industry. His journey began with the opening of his small, niche music store, 52.5, in 1997 at 52 1/2 Wentworth Street.

This compact space became a cultural hub for punk, indie-rock, and ska music enthusiasts during a period of ska revival. Initially, Jim and his team fueled their store’s inventory with their personal collection of CDs and LPs, helping the store thrive through its early days.

Since 2024, Jim Ruland has embarked on a new venture, channeling his profound knowledge and passion for music into a more digital form through informative blogging. His current work focuses on personal product analysis and firsthand usage reviews, allowing him to leverage his extensive experience in music and retail in the digital age.

Jim's blog offers insightful critiques and detailed reviews of various products, providing his audience with valuable information based on real-world experiences.