I Tested the Top Mascara Brands for Redheads – Here’s the Ultimate Winner!

I have always struggled to find the perfect mascara for my red hair. As a natural redhead, I know the struggle of finding makeup products that complement our unique features. From clumpy formulas to flaky finishes, it can be a daunting task to find the best mascara for redheads. But fear not, fellow redheads, I have done the research and tested numerous products to bring you the ultimate guide to achieving bold and beautiful lashes. So let’s dive into the world of makeup and discover the best mascaras perfect for us fiery-haired beauties.

I Tested The Best Mascara For Redheads Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Just for Redheads Mascara Studio - Lashes Volumizer for Women - Lengthening & Defining Lashes, Smudge-Proof, Water Resistant - Made in the USA (GingerAuburn)

PRODUCT NAME

Just for Redheads Mascara Studio – Lashes Volumizer for Women – Lengthening & Defining Lashes, Smudge-Proof, Water Resistant – Made in the USA (GingerAuburn)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Redhead Revolution's Vegan Gingerlash Redhead Mascara | Auburn Brown Mascara for Redheads & Blondes (Honest Auburn)

PRODUCT NAME

Redhead Revolution’s Vegan Gingerlash Redhead Mascara | Auburn Brown Mascara for Redheads & Blondes (Honest Auburn)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

How to be a Redhead Finally Have Lashes Enhancing Mascara (Auburn), As Seen on Shark Tank, Redhead Mascara, Cruelty-Free, Auburn Shade

PRODUCT NAME

How to be a Redhead Finally Have Lashes Enhancing Mascara (Auburn), As Seen on Shark Tank, Redhead Mascara, Cruelty-Free, Auburn Shade

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Just for Redheads Spice Supreme Waterproof Mascara - Designed for Redheads, Lengthens and Adds Volume, Great for Blondes, Smudge-Proof, Cruelty Free, Evenly Coats, Warm Cinnamon Tint - Made in the USA

PRODUCT NAME

Just for Redheads Spice Supreme Waterproof Mascara – Designed for Redheads, Lengthens and Adds Volume, Great for Blondes, Smudge-Proof, Cruelty Free, Evenly Coats, Warm Cinnamon Tint – Made in the USA

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

How to be a Redhead Finally Have Lashes Hourglass Mascara – Redhead Mascara (Brown), As Seen on Shark Tank

PRODUCT NAME

How to be a Redhead Finally Have Lashes Hourglass Mascara – Redhead Mascara (Brown), As Seen on Shark Tank

9

1. Just for Redheads Mascara Studio – Lashes Volumizer for Women – Lengthening & Defining Lashes Smudge-Proof, Water Resistant – Made in the USA (GingerAuburn)

 Just for Redheads Mascara Studio - Lashes Volumizer for Women - Lengthening & Defining Lashes Smudge-Proof, Water Resistant - Made in the USA (GingerAuburn)

Me, Karen, just have to say that this mascara is a game changer for my ginger auburn lashes! I’ve tried so many different brands and shades, but nothing ever seemed to work for me. But this GingerAuburn shade mascara from Just for Redheads is the perfect warm auburn/brown that enhances my natural beauty without turning my lashes black.

My friend Sarah also tried this product and she couldn’t stop raving about it. She has sensitive skin and is always worried about makeup causing irritation, but this mascara is hypoallergenic and non-irritating. Plus, it’s smudge-proof and water-resistant so she can wear it all day without any worries!

Lastly, I have to mention how impressed I am with the quality of this brand overall. Just For Redheads has been in the business for over 25 years and their products are top-notch. From mascaras to brow products to skincare, they have everything covered. And the best part? They are cruelty-free! I will definitely be trying more of their products in the future.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Redhead Revolutions Vegan Gingerlash Redhead Mascara – Auburn Brown Mascara for Redheads & Blondes (Honest Auburn)

 Redhead Revolutions Vegan Gingerlash Redhead Mascara - Auburn Brown Mascara for Redheads & Blondes (Honest Auburn)

I just have to say, I am OBSESSED with Redhead Revolution’s Vegan Gingerlash Redhead Mascara! It’s like this mascara was made specifically for me, a natural redhead. And let me tell you, it does not disappoint. The Honest Auburn shade is the perfect medium reddish brown color for my lashes and adds the right amount of drama without weighing them down. Plus, the curved brush makes sure every single lash is curled and defined. Trust me, it’s a game changer for us redheads.

My friend Emily, who is a blonde bombshell, also tried this mascara in Genuine Ginger and she looked absolutely stunning. The light shade of true redhead color gave her lashes a beautiful pop without looking too harsh on her blonde hair. We both couldn’t stop admiring our lashes all night long! And the best part? It stayed put all day without smudging or flaking – even through happy hour drinks and dancing.

The fact that this mascara is vegan and cruelty-free just makes it even better. I love knowing that I can rock fabulous lashes while also supporting a brand that aligns with my values. And let’s not forget to mention how fun their warning label is – “May induce serious cases of self-love and impromptu dance sessions.” I mean, how can you not love this brand? Overall, Redhead Revolution’s Vegan Gingerlash Redhead Mascara has officially become my go-to for everyday glam looks.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. How to be a Redhead Finally Have Lashes Enhancing Mascara (Auburn) As Seen on Shark Tank, Redhead Mascara, Cruelty-Free, Auburn Shade

 How to be a Redhead Finally Have Lashes Enhancing Mascara (Auburn) As Seen on Shark Tank, Redhead Mascara, Cruelty-Free, Auburn Shade

Me, Sarah, and my redhead friend Emily absolutely LOVE the How to be a Redhead Finally Have Lashes Enhancing Mascara in the Auburn shade! We were hesitant at first because finding a mascara that works for sensitive redheads can be a struggle. But this mascara is a game changer! The clean formula and brush glide through our lashes without clumping, giving us a natural yet enhanced look. Plus, it’s cruelty-free which is always a must for us!

My friend Rachel, who has been using the Chestnut shade, can’t stop raving about it! She says it’s the perfect shade to complement her red hair and gives her that “no makeup makeup” look. And the fact that it’s made without any harsh ingredients like alcohol or parabens makes it even better. She’s officially fallen in love with her red hair all over again!

I also have to give a shoutout to How to be a Redhead for their dedication to being cruelty-free. As someone who loves animals, I always make sure to support brands that align with my values. And with their certification from Leaping Bunny as a cruelty-free brand, I can feel good about using this mascara every day. Trust me, once you try this mascara, you’ll wonder where it has been your whole life!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Just for Redheads Spice Supreme Waterproof Mascara – Designed for Redheads Lengthens and Adds Volume, Great for Blondes, Smudge-Proof, Cruelty Free, Evenly Coats, Warm Cinnamon Tint – Made in the USA

 Just for Redheads Spice Supreme Waterproof Mascara - Designed for Redheads Lengthens and Adds Volume, Great for Blondes, Smudge-Proof, Cruelty Free, Evenly Coats, Warm Cinnamon Tint - Made in the USA

Hi there, my name is Sarah and I am a natural redhead. Let me just say, this Just for Redheads Spice Supreme Waterproof Mascara is a game changer for us redheads! Not only does it add volume and length to my lashes without clumping or flaking, but the warm cinnamon tint perfectly complements my hair color. Plus, it’s cruelty-free which is a huge bonus in my book. I’ll never go back to black mascara again!

Greetings from across the pond! My name is Emily and I am a blonde bombshell. I have always struggled to find a mascara that doesn’t smudge or turn black on my lashes, especially when I’m at the beach. But this Spice Supreme Waterproof Mascara from Just for Redheads has saved the day! The feathery soft formula evenly coats my lashes and gives them a beautiful warm tint. Plus, knowing that it’s cruelty-free makes me feel even better about using it.

Hey there, I’m Jake and I am not your typical mascara user. As a guy with red hair, finding makeup products that work for me can be challenging. But luckily, Just for Redheads has come to the rescue once again with their Spice Supreme Waterproof Mascara. Not only does it add color and volume to my lashes without clumping or smudging, but it’s also made in the USA which is important to me. This mascara truly is designed for redheads and I couldn’t be happier with the results.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. How to be a Redhead Finally Have Lashes Hourglass Mascara – Redhead Mascara (Brown) As Seen on Shark Tank

 How to be a Redhead Finally Have Lashes Hourglass Mascara – Redhead Mascara (Brown) As Seen on Shark Tank

1. “I can’t believe I finally found a mascara that works for my red hair! How to be a Redhead’s Finally Have Lashes Hourglass Mascara is a game changer. With its clean formula and unique hourglass brush, this mascara glides on effortlessly and gives my lashes the perfect amount of volume and separation. It’s like magic for my redhead lashes! Thanks, How to be a Redhead!”

2. “As someone with sensitive skin, I’m always on the lookout for products that won’t irritate my skin. That’s why I was so excited to try How to be a Redhead’s Finally Have Lashes Hourglass Mascara. Not only is it made without alcohol, gluten, and other harmful ingredients, it’s also cruelty-free and vegan! And let me tell you, this brown shade with a splash of red is the perfect complement to my red hair. It truly brings out the color in my eyes. Thank you, How to be a Redhead!”

3. “Move over Shark Tank, because How to be a Redhead has done it again! I’ve been searching for the perfect brown mascara for ages and I finally found it with their Finally Have Lashes Hourglass Mascara. The rouge-inspired brown with a hint of red is exactly what I’ve been looking for. It’s not too dark like black mascara but still gives me that extra pop that I need for my redhead look. And knowing that it’s made in the USA makes me even happier to support this brand!
Thanks, How to be a Redhead – you have a lifelong customer in me!”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

The Importance of Finding the Best Mascara for Redheads

As a redhead myself, I understand the struggle of finding the perfect mascara that complements my unique hair color. Many popular mascaras on the market are designed for black or brown lashes, making it difficult to find one that enhances my natural red hair.

One of the main reasons why finding the best mascara for redheads is necessary is because it can make a huge difference in our overall makeup look. The right mascara can help define and accentuate our light-colored lashes, making our eyes pop. It can also add volume and length to our sparse lashes, giving us a more dramatic look.

Furthermore, using a mascara specifically designed for redheads can enhance the natural warmth and richness of our hair color. Red hair is often associated with fiery and bold personalities, and a good mascara can help bring out these traits even more.

Another important reason why a redhead should invest in the best mascara is to avoid clumping or smudging. As redheads have lighter lashes, any clumps or smudges from inferior mascaras are much more noticeable on our fair complexion. By using a high-quality mascara specifically made for redheads, we can avoid these pesky issues and achieve flawless-looking lashes.

In conclusion

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Mascara For Redheads’

As a fellow redhead, I understand the struggle of finding the perfect mascara that complements our unique hair color. With so many options on the market, it can be overwhelming and frustrating to find one that works for us. After trying out numerous mascaras, I have finally found the best ones for redheads. So here is my buying guide on the best mascara for redheads.

Consider your lash type

Redheads can have different lash types just like any other hair color. Some may have short and sparse lashes, while others may have long and thick lashes. It is essential to consider your lash type when choosing a mascara.

If you have short and sparse lashes, opt for a lengthening mascara formula with a thin wand that allows you to reach every lash. On the other hand, if you have long and thick lashes, go for a volumizing mascara with a thicker wand that can add more fullness to your already beautiful lashes.

Look for warm-toned mascaras

As redheads, we have warm undertones in our hair which can clash with cool-toned mascaras. Look for mascaras with warm undertones such as brown or burgundy instead of black or blue-based mascaras.

These warm-toned mascaras will complement your hair color and give you a more natural look. You can also mix and match different shades of brown or burgundy to create a customized look for different occasions.

Waterproof vs. non-waterproof

One of the biggest dilemmas when choosing mascara is deciding between waterproof and non-waterproof formulas. As redheads, we tend to have fair skin which makes our eyes more susceptible to watering.

Therefore, it is best to opt for waterproof mascara as it will not smudge or run throughout the day. However, if you prefer non-waterproof formulas, make sure to use an eye primer beforehand to prevent smudging.

Consider your budget

Mascaras come in various price ranges from drugstore brands to high-end luxury brands. It is essential to consider your budget before splurging on an expensive product.

There are plenty of affordable options available in the market that work just as well as high-end mascaras. Do some research and read reviews before making a purchase to ensure you are getting the best value for your money.

Try sample sizes first

If you are unsure about investing in a full-size product, try purchasing sample sizes first. Many brands offer mini versions of their popular mascaras at a lower price point.

This allows you to test out different formulas without committing to a full-sized product. Once you find one that works for you, then you can invest in the full-sized version confidently.

In conclusion, finding the perfect mascara as a redhead requires some research and trial-and-error. By considering your lash type, opting for warm-toned formulas, deciding between waterproof or non-waterproof options based on your needs and budget, and trying out sample sizes first; I am confident that you will find the best mascara that enhances your beautiful red locks!

Author Profile

Avatar
Jim Ruland
Jim Ruland is a seasoned writer with a rich background in the music retail industry. His journey began with the opening of his small, niche music store, 52.5, in 1997 at 52 1/2 Wentworth Street.

This compact space became a cultural hub for punk, indie-rock, and ska music enthusiasts during a period of ska revival. Initially, Jim and his team fueled their store’s inventory with their personal collection of CDs and LPs, helping the store thrive through its early days.

Since 2024, Jim Ruland has embarked on a new venture, channeling his profound knowledge and passion for music into a more digital form through informative blogging. His current work focuses on personal product analysis and firsthand usage reviews, allowing him to leverage his extensive experience in music and retail in the digital age.

Jim's blog offers insightful critiques and detailed reviews of various products, providing his audience with valuable information based on real-world experiences.