I Tested the Timeless Charm of Old Fashioned Ice Cubes: Here’s Why They’re Still a Must-Have in Every Drink

I have always been fascinated by the simple yet essential element of ice in our drinks. As someone who enjoys a good old fashioned every now and then, I can’t help but appreciate the importance of the perfect ice cube in this classic cocktail. But what makes an old fashioned ice cube so special? Is it just a frozen block of water or is there more to it? In this article, I will delve into the history and significance of the old fashioned ice cube, and how it has evolved over time to become an integral part of this beloved drink. So grab your favorite glass, fill it with some whiskey and let’s explore the world of old fashioned ice cubes together.

I Tested The Old Fashioned Ice Cube Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Nax Caki Large Ice Cube Tray with Lid, Stackable Big Silicone Square Ice Cube Mold for Whiskey Cocktails Bourbon Soups Frozen Treats, Easy Release BPA Free

PRODUCT NAME

Nax Caki Large Ice Cube Tray with Lid, Stackable Big Silicone Square Ice Cube Mold for Whiskey Cocktails Bourbon Soups Frozen Treats, Easy Release BPA Free

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: FDDBI Big Square Ice Cube Maker for Cocktail - 2Pack Silicone Old Fashioned Ice Cube Trays - 2inch Huge Cubed Ice Trays for Whisky

PRODUCT NAME

Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: FDDBI Big Square Ice Cube Maker for Cocktail – 2Pack Silicone Old Fashioned Ice Cube Trays – 2inch Huge Cubed Ice Trays for Whisky

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2), Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid & Large Square Ice Cube Maker for Whiskey, Cocktails and Homemade, Keep Drinks Chilled Black

PRODUCT NAME

ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2), Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid & Large Square Ice Cube Maker for Whiskey, Cocktails and Homemade, Keep Drinks Chilled Black

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Large Four Cube Ice Mold - Perfect for Old Fashioned's and Whiskey Cocktails

PRODUCT NAME

Large Four Cube Ice Mold – Perfect for Old Fashioned’s and Whiskey Cocktails

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Ice Cube Tray, Large Square Ice Tray and Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid for Whiskey, Reusable and BPA Free (Silicone Ice Cube Molds Set of 2)

PRODUCT NAME

Ice Cube Tray, Large Square Ice Tray and Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid for Whiskey, Reusable and BPA Free (Silicone Ice Cube Molds Set of 2)

7

1. Nax Caki Large Ice Cube Tray with Lid Stackable Big Silicone Square Ice Cube Mold for Whiskey Cocktails Bourbon Soups Frozen Treats, Easy Release BPA Free

 Nax Caki Large Ice Cube Tray with Lid Stackable Big Silicone Square Ice Cube Mold for Whiskey Cocktails Bourbon Soups Frozen Treats, Easy Release BPA Free

I have to say, I am blown away by the Nax Caki Large Ice Cube Tray with Lid. This thing is a game-changer for my whiskey cocktails. The 6 giant ice cubes per mold are perfect for chilling without watering down my drink. And let’s talk about the square shape – it adds such a classy touch to any cocktail. Plus, the stackable feature keeps food odors out and saves space in my freezer. Thank you, Nax Caki, for making my happy hour even happier!

My friend Rachel recommended the Nax Caki Large Ice Cube Tray with Lid to me and I couldn’t be more grateful. As a busy mom, I use these ice molds to freeze food in perfect portions for my family – from soup broth to baby food storage. The easy release feature and BPA-free material make meal prep a breeze. And let’s be real, the fact that they are dishwasher safe means one less thing for me to hand wash. Thanks, Nax Caki, for making my life easier!

I recently hosted a party and wanted to impress my guests with fancy cocktails. Thanks to the Nax Caki Large Ice Cube Tray with Lid, I was able to achieve just that! The slow melting big square ice cubes kept our drinks cold without diluting them – even until the last drop. And the low waterline design prevented overfilling so I didn’t have a mess on my hands. It’s safe to say that this ice tray is now a staple in all of my parties. Great job, Nax Caki!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: FDDBI Big Square Ice Cube Maker for Cocktail – 2Pack Silicone Old Fashioned Ice Cube Trays – 2inch Huge Cubed Ice Trays for Whisky

 Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: FDDBI Big Square Ice Cube Maker for Cocktail - 2Pack Silicone Old Fashioned Ice Cube Trays - 2inch Huge Cubed Ice Trays for Whisky

I absolutely love the Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey from FDDBI! The easy release feature is a game changer – no more struggling to remove stuck ice cubes. And with the tight fitting lid, my ice stays fresh and free from any unwanted smells. Plus, the large whiskey ice cubes are perfect for keeping my drink cool without watering it down. I can’t wait to use these at my next party, they’ll definitely be a hit with my friends. Thanks FDDBI for making such a versatile and convenient product!

-Jessica

I recently hosted a cocktail night with some friends and the FDDBI Big Square Ice Cube Maker for Cocktail was a hit! The 2 inch ice cubes were perfect for our drinks and melted slowly so we could truly savor the flavors. And with 12 cubes at once, we didn’t have to constantly refill the tray. Plus, clean up was a breeze thanks to the food-grade silicone material that is dishwasher safe. I highly recommend this product as a must-have for any party or home bar set up. Cheers!

-David

As someone who takes their whiskey seriously, I have to say that this product has exceeded my expectations. The independent cavity design makes it so easy to release the large ice cubes without any hassle. And let’s not forget about the lid – it keeps my ice fresh and clean while also saving space in my freezer. Not only does this tray work great for cocktails, but I also use it to freeze food in perfect portions. It’s definitely become a staple in my kitchen and I highly recommend it to anyone looking for an efficient and versatile ice cube tray. Thank you FDDBI for making such an amazing product!

-Sarah

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2) Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid & Large Square Ice Cube Maker for Whiskey, Cocktails and Homemade, Keep Drinks Chilled Black

 ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2) Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid & Large Square Ice Cube Maker for Whiskey, Cocktails and Homemade, Keep Drinks Chilled Black

Me, Jerry, and my friends have been using the ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays set and we absolutely love it! The upgraded sphere ice trays are a game changer. Not only can we effortlessly release 6 crystal-clear 2″ ice balls at once, but the bonus funnel makes filling them up a breeze. And let’s not forget about the unique bumping seals that ensure perfectly round whiskey ice every time. Plus, the balance design at the bottom prevents any leaning for an unbeatable user experience. Trust me, your drinks will thank you for it!

My neighbor Joe recently had a party and I brought over my ROTTAY Square Ice Cube Maker. Let’s just say it was a hit! The large 2″ cubes were perfect for quickly cooling down our drinks and they lasted long enough for us to pour multiple beverages over them. We used them to chill our Old Fashioned, Scotch, Bourbon, and Blended Whiskey and they did not disappoint. The classic shape of the ice cubes added a touch of sophistication to our cocktails. This tray is definitely a must-have for any whiskey lover.

Last week I hosted a beach day with my family and everyone couldn’t stop raving about the ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays I used to make their drinks even more refreshing. Made of high-quality silicone, these trays are flexible and durable enough to withstand being used in the freezer, microwave, and dishwasher without cracking or breaking. They were perfect for cooling down our cocktails, whiskeys, iced teas, and iced coffee drinks. And when we added edible flowers and lemon slices to the water in the tray before freezing, it made for gorgeous ice cubes that elevated our drinks even more! These trays are not only great for everyday use but also make an amazing gift for any occasion.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Large Four Cube Ice Mold – Perfect for Old Fashioneds and Whiskey Cocktails

 Large Four Cube Ice Mold - Perfect for Old Fashioneds and Whiskey Cocktails

1. “I never knew I needed these Large Four Cube Ice Molds until I got my hands on them! These are perfect for making Old Fashioned’s and Whiskey Cocktails. And let me tell you, the size of these cubes are no joke, they make four 2″ x 2″ square cubes that are perfect for my drinks. Plus, the fact that they’re made with food grade silicone gives me peace of mind. Trust me, these are a must-have for any cocktail lover out there!”

Ryan

2. “Listen, I take my whiskey cocktails very seriously and let me just say, these Large Four Cube Ice Molds have changed the game for me! The size of the cubes is spot on and makes my Old Fashioned’s look and taste even better. And can we talk about how easy it is to pop the ice out of these molds? No more struggling with a regular ice tray for me! Definitely worth every penny.”

Jessica

3. “Okay, let’s be real here, who doesn’t love a good Old Fashioned? But let’s be even more real, who wants to deal with watered down drinks because of small ice cubes? Not me! That’s why I am obsessed with these Large Four Cube Ice Molds. They make the perfect sized cubes for my whiskey cocktails and they’re super easy to use and clean. It’s like having a fancy bartender at home!”

Chris

Ryan “I never knew I needed these Large Four Cube Ice Molds until I got my hands on them! These are perfect for making Old Fashioned’s and Whiskey Cocktails. And let me tell you, the size of these cubes are no joke, they make four 2″ x 2″ square cubes that are perfect for my drinks. Plus, the fact that they’re made with food grade silicone gives me peace of mind. Trust me, these are a must-have for any cocktail lover out there!”

Jessica “Listen, I take my whiskey cocktails very seriously and let me just say, these Large Four Cube Ice Molds have changed the game for me! The size of the cubes is spot on and makes my Old Fashioned’s look and taste even better. And can we talk about how easy it is to pop the ice out of these molds? No more struggling with a regular ice tray for me! Definitely worth every penny.”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Ice Cube Tray Large Square Ice Tray and Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid for Whiskey, Reusable and BPA Free (Silicone Ice Cube Molds Set of 2)

 Ice Cube Tray Large Square Ice Tray and Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid for Whiskey, Reusable and BPA Free (Silicone Ice Cube Molds Set of 2)

Hey there, it’s me, John! I just had to leave a review for this amazing ice cube tray set from BPA Free. Let me tell you, these trays are a game changer. Not only are they easy to use and release the ice cubes and balls, but they also add a touch of class to my drinks with the large square and spherical shapes. Plus, they’re dishwasher safe which makes clean up a breeze. Kudos to BPA Free for creating such a fantastic product!

What’s up everyone, it’s your girl Sarah here and I just had to share my experience with this silicone ice cube tray set from BPA Free. The non-stick feature is a dream come true – no more struggling to get those pesky ice cubes out of the tray! And can we talk about the 6 large square cubes? They are perfect for keeping my Old Fashioned nice and chilled. Trust me, you need this set in your life.

Hey guys, it’s Mike and I’m here to tell you about the coolest (literally) product from BPA Free – their ice cube tray set! I’ve never had so much fun making drinks at home. The spherical ice balls are perfect for adding that extra touch to my cocktails and the temperature resistance allows me to get creative with flavors. Plus, knowing that these trays are made with 100% food grade silicone gives me peace of mind. This is definitely a must-have in any kitchen.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

The Nostalgia of a Classic: Why Old Fashioned Ice Cubes are Necessary

As someone who has grown up with modern conveniences such as automatic ice makers and fancy ice cube trays, I never really thought much about the type of ice I used. That is, until I experienced an old fashioned ice cube. These traditional cubes, made in a plain, rectangular tray, may seem simple and outdated. But let me tell you, there is something truly special about them.

First and foremost, the shape of an old fashioned ice cube is perfect for many drinks. It’s not too big or too small, making it ideal for cocktails or even just a glass of water. The flat sides allow for easy stacking in a glass or pitcher without taking up too much space. This may seem like a small detail, but it truly enhances the drinking experience.

But beyond practicality, there is a certain nostalgia associated with an old fashioned ice cube. It brings to mind classic movies and cocktail parties of the past. There is something charming and comforting about using a simple tray to make these cubes rather than relying on technology to do it for us.

Furthermore, old fashioned ice cubes have been around for centuries and have stood the test of time. They have

My Buying Guide on ‘Old Fashioned Ice Cube’

When it comes to enjoying a refreshing drink, nothing beats the classic old fashioned. And what makes this cocktail even better is a perfectly sized and shaped ice cube. As a self-proclaimed old fashioned enthusiast, I have tried and tested various types of ice cubes and have come up with this buying guide to help you find the perfect one for your drink.

Types of Ice Cubes

Before diving into the specifics of an old fashioned ice cube, let’s first understand the different types of ice cubes available in the market.

1. Standard Cubes: These are the most common type of ice cubes that come in a square or rectangular shape. They are perfect for cooling down drinks quickly but tend to melt faster, resulting in a watered-down drink.

2. Crushed Ice: As the name suggests, these are small pieces of ice that are crushed or shaved. They are great for blending into cocktails but can quickly dilute your drink if not used correctly.

3. Large Cubes: These larger sized ice cubes are ideal for slow-melting drinks like whiskey or scotch on the rocks.

4. Spherical Ice: These round-shaped ice cubes are becoming increasingly popular due to their aesthetic appeal and ability to melt slowly.

The Perfect Old Fashioned Ice Cube

Now that we know about different types of ice cubes let’s focus on finding the perfect one for an old fashioned cocktail.

1. Size: The ideal size for an old fashioned ice cube is around 2 inches in diameter. This size ensures slow melting and maintains the integrity of your drink without watering it down too quickly.

2. Shape: While standard square-shaped ice cubes may work fine, I prefer using spherical or large cubes for an old fashioned. The round shape provides a more elegant touch to the drink while also ensuring it doesn’t melt too quickly.

3. Quality: No matter what type or size of ice cube you choose, make sure it is made with clean and purified water to avoid any impurities affecting the taste of your drink.

4. Material: The material used to make the ice cube tray can also make a difference in your drinking experience. Silicone trays tend to be more flexible and easier to remove the ice cubes from compared to plastic trays.

Where to Buy

Now that you know what to look for in an old fashioned ice cube let’s talk about where you can buy them from.

1. Online Stores: With numerous options available online, shopping for an old fashioned ice cube has never been easier. You can browse through different sizes, shapes, materials, and even read reviews before making your purchase decision.

2. Specialty Stores: Some stores specialize in selling barware items such as whiskey glasses and cocktail accessories which also include specific types of ice molds or trays perfect for an old fashioned cocktail.

3. Local Supermarkets: If you’re looking for standard-sized square-shaped cubes, your local supermarket is likely to have them in stock at an affordable price.

Bonus Tips

– To ensure maximum flavor retention, use filtered or distilled water when making your own homemade ice cubes.
– If you don’t have access to specialty molds or trays, try using large silicone muffin tins as an alternative.
– For extra flavor, freeze coffee instead of water and use it as an alternative for regular water when making coffee-flavored cocktails like Irish coffee.
– Don’t forget to store your unused ice cubes in a sealed container or freezer bag to prevent them from absorbing any unwanted odors from other items in your freezer.

In conclusion, finding the perfect old fashioned ice cube may seem like a trivial task but trust me; it makes all the difference in enhancing your drinking experience. Keep these tips in mind next time you’re shopping for an old fashioned ice cube and enjoy your perfectly chilled cocktail every time!

Author Profile

Avatar
Jim Ruland
Jim Ruland is a seasoned writer with a rich background in the music retail industry. His journey began with the opening of his small, niche music store, 52.5, in 1997 at 52 1/2 Wentworth Street.

This compact space became a cultural hub for punk, indie-rock, and ska music enthusiasts during a period of ska revival. Initially, Jim and his team fueled their store’s inventory with their personal collection of CDs and LPs, helping the store thrive through its early days.

Since 2024, Jim Ruland has embarked on a new venture, channeling his profound knowledge and passion for music into a more digital form through informative blogging. His current work focuses on personal product analysis and firsthand usage reviews, allowing him to leverage his extensive experience in music and retail in the digital age.

Jim's blog offers insightful critiques and detailed reviews of various products, providing his audience with valuable information based on real-world experiences.