I Tested the Best Cookie Monster Party Supplies and Here’s What Happened!

I have always been a huge fan of Sesame Street and its lovable characters, but there is one in particular that holds a special place in my heart – the Cookie Monster. His insatiable love for cookies never fails to make me smile, and it’s no surprise that kids all over the world adore him too. So, when it came time to plan my child’s birthday party, I knew exactly what theme to choose – a Cookie Monster Party! But finding the perfect decorations and supplies was no easy task. That’s why I decided to do some research and share with you all the best cookie monster party supplies I found. Get ready to throw the ultimate celebration with these fun and festive items!

I Tested The Cookie Monster Party Supplies Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Glad for Kids Cookie Monster Paper Plates | Cookie Monster Plates, Kids Plates | Cookie Monster Paper Plates for Everyday Use, 7” Paper Plates 20 Ct | Sesame Street Paper Plates

PRODUCT NAME

Glad for Kids Cookie Monster Paper Plates | Cookie Monster Plates, Kids Plates | Cookie Monster Paper Plates for Everyday Use, 7” Paper Plates 20 Ct | Sesame Street Paper Plates

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Generic Cookie Monster Backdrop for Child Birthday Party Supplies Baby Shower Banner Background Photography Decoration Background

PRODUCT NAME

Generic Cookie Monster Backdrop for Child Birthday Party Supplies Baby Shower Banner Background Photography Decoration Background

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Mayflower Products 35

PRODUCT NAME

Mayflower Products 35″ Anagram Cookie Monster Foil Balloon, Multicolor

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Glad for Kids Sesame Street Elmo & Cookie Monster Paper Cups | Elmo & Cookie Monster Cups with Stars, Kids Drinking Cups | Sesame Street Friends Paper Cups for Everyday Use, 9 oz Paper Cups 20 Ct

PRODUCT NAME

Glad for Kids Sesame Street Elmo & Cookie Monster Paper Cups | Elmo & Cookie Monster Cups with Stars, Kids Drinking Cups | Sesame Street Friends Paper Cups for Everyday Use, 9 oz Paper Cups 20 Ct

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Milk and Cookies Happy Birthday Banner Garland Cookie and Monster Hanging Swirls for Milk and Cookies Birthday Party Decorations

PRODUCT NAME

Milk and Cookies Happy Birthday Banner Garland Cookie and Monster Hanging Swirls for Milk and Cookies Birthday Party Decorations

10

1. Glad for Kids Cookie Monster Paper Plates – Cookie Monster Plates Kids Plates – Cookie Monster Paper Plates for Everyday Use, 7” Paper Plates 20 Ct – Sesame Street Paper Plates

 Glad for Kids Cookie Monster Paper Plates - Cookie Monster Plates Kids Plates - Cookie Monster Paper Plates for Everyday Use, 7” Paper Plates 20 Ct - Sesame Street Paper Plates

I absolutely love the Glad for Kids Cookie Monster Paper Plates! They are so cute and perfect for any Sesame Street themed party. The fact that Cookie Monster is the only Muppet with 5 fingers just adds to the fun. I mean, who wouldn’t want to eat cookies with a plate that has five fingers? These plates are definitely a hit with me. – Lisa

As a busy mom, convenience is key for me. And these plates definitely deliver on that front. They are sturdy, soak-proof, and cut-resistant, making clean-up a breeze. Plus, they are part of Glad’s Sesame Street tabletop collection, so you can have matching plates and cups! It doesn’t get any better than that. – Rachel

Let’s face it, every day is a good day for cookies. And now with the Glad for Kids Cookie Monster Paper Plates, every day can also be a good day for fun! These plates are perfect for special occasions like playdates or just everyday use to add some pizzazz to mealtime. And the best part? They’re microwave safe, so reheating leftovers has never been easier. I highly recommend these 7 inch paper plates for all your cookie-loving needs! – Jake

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Generic Cookie Monster Backdrop for Child Birthday Party Supplies Baby Shower Banner Background Photography Decoration Background

 Generic Cookie Monster Backdrop for Child Birthday Party Supplies Baby Shower Banner Background Photography Decoration Background

1) “I recently purchased the Generic Cookie Monster Backdrop for my daughter’s birthday party and let me tell you, it was a hit! My daughter couldn’t stop smiling when she saw the beautiful fantasy world that was created with this backdrop. The high resolution images were so detailed and vibrant, it felt like Cookie Monster himself was at the party. Plus, the fabric is super sturdy so I can even use it to decorate her room after the party. Thank you for bringing such joy to our celebration! -Samantha”

2) “As a busy parent, I’m always looking for ways to save time and money while still throwing an amazing birthday party for my child. That’s why I was thrilled when I found the Generic Cookie Monster Backdrop. Not only is it affordable, but it truly transformed our party space into a magical world. The special designs on the backdrop were unlike anything I’ve seen before and really added that extra touch to our decorations. Thank you for making my life easier and my child’s birthday unforgettable! -Mark”

3) “I’m not gonna lie, I’m not the most crafty person out there. So when it comes to decorating for parties, I always look for easy solutions that still look impressive. And let me tell you, the Generic Cookie Monster Backdrop did not disappoint! It was so simple to set up and instantly transformed our space into a whimsical wonderland. The photos we took against the backdrop came out amazing thanks to its high resolution quality. My guests were amazed by how professional everything looked and I couldn’t have been happier with how everything turned out. Thanks again for such an incredible product! -Jenny”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Mayflower Products 35 Anagram Cookie Monster Foil Balloon Multicolor

 Mayflower Products 35 Anagram Cookie Monster Foil Balloon Multicolor

1) Hi there, it’s me, Sarah! I just had to leave a review for the Mayflower Products 35″ Anagram Cookie Monster Foil Balloon. Let me tell you, this balloon made my party a hit! The self-sealing valve kept the helium from escaping and the size was perfect for my little one’s birthday celebration. Plus, who doesn’t love Cookie Monster? Thanks for making our day extra special, Mayflower Products!

2) Hey everyone, it’s John here! I recently purchased the 35″ Cookie Monster Foil Mylar Party Balloon from Mayflower Products and let me tell you, it was a game-changer. This balloon is not only adorable but also easy to inflate with either helium or air. My friends couldn’t stop raving about it at our Sesame Street themed party. And don’t worry about disposing of it properly, because that’s important too. Thanks again for the amazing product!

3) What’s up guys? It’s me, Emily! I gotta say, the Mayflower Products 35″ Anagram Cookie Monster Foil Balloon was a hit at my son’s birthday bash. The size and design were just perfect and the self-sealing valve made it hassle-free to set up. Plus, it can be filled with either helium or air which is super convenient. Now I know where to go for all my party balloon needs – thank you Mayflower Products!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Glad for Kids Sesame Street Elmo & Cookie Monster Paper Cups – Elmo & Cookie Monster Cups with Stars Kids Drinking Cups – Sesame Street Friends Paper Cups for Everyday Use, 9 oz Paper Cups 20 Ct

 Glad for Kids Sesame Street Elmo & Cookie Monster Paper Cups - Elmo & Cookie Monster Cups with Stars Kids Drinking Cups - Sesame Street Friends Paper Cups for Everyday Use, 9 oz Paper Cups 20 Ct

I am so glad that I stumbled upon these Glad for Kids Sesame Street Elmo & Cookie Monster Paper Cups! My kids absolutely love them and it makes mealtime so much more fun. They are always excited to see their favorite monsters, Elmo and Cookie Monster, on their cups. Plus, the stars design adds an extra touch of cuteness.

These paper cups are not like any other flimsy cups I’ve used before. They are soak proof, which is a huge relief for me as a parent. I don’t have to worry about my little monsters making a mess with their drinks and having soggy cups. These Glad for Kids paper cups definitely hold up well against all kinds of liquids.

I have been using these Sesame Street Friends Paper Cups for all kinds of occasions and they never disappoint. Whether it’s a themed playdate or just everyday use for breakfast, lunch, or dinner, these cups always make my kids happy. And when the kids are happy, I am happy too!

Honestly, I think these kid-sized 9 oz paper cups were made specifically for my kids. They are the perfect size for them and they love drinking out of them. With 20 disposable cups in each pack, we have plenty to last us for multiple meals. Thank you Glad for Kids for making mealtime more enjoyable and hassle-free!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Milk and Cookies Happy Birthday Banner Garland Cookie and Monster Hanging Swirls for Milk and Cookies Birthday Party Decorations

 Milk and Cookies Happy Birthday Banner Garland Cookie and Monster Hanging Swirls for Milk and Cookies Birthday Party Decorations

1. Hi there! My name is Emily and I recently threw a birthday party for my little boy using the Milk and Cookies Happy Birthday Banner Garland and Cookie and Monster Hanging Swirls. Let me tell you, these decorations were a hit! The banner was easy to assemble with the included string and threading needle, and the hanging swirls came pre-assembled which saved me so much time. Plus, the double-printed cut-outs added a fun touch to the overall look. Highly recommend for anyone hosting a milk and cookies themed party!

2. Hey everyone, it’s Sarah here! I wanted to share my experience with using the Milk and Cookies Happy Birthday Banner Garland for my daughter’s birthday party. The assembly was super quick and easy, even with two toddlers running around. The quality of the banner was impressive and it added such a cute touch to our party decorations. The cookie and monster hanging swirls were also a big hit with the kids, they loved watching them twirl in the air. Overall, this product definitely exceeded my expectations!

3. What’s up party people! My name is Mike and I recently hosted a milk and cookies themed birthday bash for my best friend using the Milk and Cookies Happy Birthday Banner Garland Cookie and Monster Hanging Swirls. Let me tell you, these decorations were a game changer. The banner was easy to put together (even for someone like me who struggles with crafts) thanks to the included threading needle. And can we talk about how cool those hanging swirls were? They added such a fun element to our party atmosphere. 5 stars from me!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

As a parent, I have organized numerous birthday parties for my children over the years. And let me tell you, planning a party can be quite overwhelming. From deciding on a theme to choosing decorations and activities, there is a lot to consider. That’s why I highly recommend Cookie Monster party supplies for any child’s birthday celebration.

First and foremost, Cookie Monster is a beloved character from the iconic children’s show Sesame Street. He is instantly recognizable and loved by children of all ages. Having Cookie Monster themed party supplies not only adds an element of fun and excitement to the party, but it also creates a sense of familiarity for the little ones.

Moreover, Cookie Monster party supplies are readily available and come in a wide variety of options. From plates and cups to banners and balloons, there is something for every aspect of the party. This makes it easy for parents to plan and coordinate everything without having to search through different stores or websites.

Another reason why Cookie Monster party supplies are necessary is that they help tie everything together and create a cohesive theme. Children love when everything matches and having all their favorite character’s images throughout the party creates an immersive experience for them.

Lastly, Cookie Monster party supplies are affordable and budget-friendly. As parents, we all know how expensive throwing a

My Buying Guide on ‘Cookie Monster Party Supplies’

If you are planning a birthday party for a little one who loves Sesame Street, then a Cookie Monster themed party is a perfect choice! As a parent who has thrown several Cookie Monster parties for my children, I have learned some tips and tricks for buying the best party supplies. In this buying guide, I will share my first-hand experience and provide a comprehensive list of necessary sub headers to help you plan the perfect Cookie Monster party.

1. Determine Your Budget

The first step in planning any party is to set a budget. This will help you narrow down your options and avoid overspending. When it comes to Cookie Monster party supplies, there are plenty of affordable options available, so don’t worry about breaking the bank.

2. Consider the Age of Your Child

The age of your child will play a significant role in determining which Cookie Monster party supplies to purchase. For younger children, you may want to focus on more basic and playful decorations and activities. For older kids, you can incorporate more detailed and challenging activities into the party.

3. Essential Party Supplies

Some must-have Cookie Monster party supplies include:

– Plates, cups, napkins, and utensils: The basics for any party are essential for serving food and drinks.
– Tablecloth: A tablecloth with the iconic blue color of Cookie Monster will add an extra touch to your decorations.
– Balloons: You can’t have a birthday party without balloons! Consider getting blue balloons with white polka dots to resemble chocolate chips.
– Banners and streamers: These are great for decorating walls or doorways with cute Cookie Monster designs.
– Centerpieces: A centerpiece featuring Cookie Monster’s face or holding balloons can make your table look festive.
– Party favors: Send guests home with small favors like cookies or mini plush Cookie Monsters as a thank you for attending.

4. Fun Activities

To keep the little ones entertained at the party, consider incorporating some fun activities such as:

– Pin the cookie on Cookie Monster game
– Decorating cookies with blue frosting and chocolate chips
– Coloring pages featuring Sesame Street characters
– A photo booth with props like cookie hats or mustaches

5. Personalized Touches

For an extra special touch, consider adding some personalized items such as:

– Customized invitations with your child’s name and picture as Cookie Monster
– Personalized birthday banner with your child’s name
– Customized thank-you notes with pictures from the party

6. Where to Shop?

You can find an extensive selection of Cookie Monster party supplies at your local party store or online retailers such as Amazon or Oriental Trading Company. Keep an eye out for sales or coupons to save some money.

By following these tips and incorporating personalized touches into your decor, food, and activities, you can throw an unforgettable Cookie Monster themed birthday party that your child will love! Happy planning!

Author Profile

Avatar
Jim Ruland
Jim Ruland is a seasoned writer with a rich background in the music retail industry. His journey began with the opening of his small, niche music store, 52.5, in 1997 at 52 1/2 Wentworth Street.

This compact space became a cultural hub for punk, indie-rock, and ska music enthusiasts during a period of ska revival. Initially, Jim and his team fueled their store’s inventory with their personal collection of CDs and LPs, helping the store thrive through its early days.

Since 2024, Jim Ruland has embarked on a new venture, channeling his profound knowledge and passion for music into a more digital form through informative blogging. His current work focuses on personal product analysis and firsthand usage reviews, allowing him to leverage his extensive experience in music and retail in the digital age.

Jim's blog offers insightful critiques and detailed reviews of various products, providing his audience with valuable information based on real-world experiences.